Skip to content

Investing · · 4 min

Alpha vs. Beta in Investment

Archived article from 5 November 2020. Prices, results and products change, so check the current details before you buy or trade.

Success in the stock market depends on how smartly you invest. There are several strategies and methods used by investors to capitalize on the market movement and reap profits. Alpha and Beta are two such investment-related concepts that help you assess the risks involved and measure your profits.

Knowledge of the two terms can give you the leverage needed for understanding the investing concept better. Read on to know what these two concepts are, their differences, and their significance for an investor. 

Alpha

The outperformance value of a stock is measured as Alpha. It denotes the difference in the value of the actual returns of a fund and its expected returns for a specific Beta value. So, a positive value denotes the outperformance of a fund in relation to a standard index. A value of 3 denotes a stock has delivered 3% higher returns. And, a negative value indicates lower returns in relation to the benchmark or standard index used.

How the Alpha value influences your stock 

The values usually help in ranking the performance of funds. They also help in verifying a security’s performance in relation to the standard index.

Assessing the Alpha value of your stock

To calculate the Alpha value of a stock, the following formula is used:

Alpha = Actual return rate of a stock – Expected return rate

How to find actual and expected returns?

For the actual returns, you have to tabulate the historical returns of stock for the duration you want. 

The expected return is a value prediction that indicates the probability of positive returns of an investment. The historical information on previous investment returns of a stock is used for assessing the probable returns. It is an aggregate total of the returns of various periods assessed.

Beta

Beta is used for measuring the historical volatility of an asset in relation to a benchmark index. Therefore, a high Beta value indicates high risk and volatility.

Why is it critical for stock selection?

Beta measurement is critical as you can understand the risk involved and make a safer investment. The measure indicates all eventual outcomes of an investment that you are considering. So, you can use the value to verify whether a stock is suitable or not.

A few values and their significance

  • 0 value correlates with the basic standard index.
  • 0 to 1 indicates low volatility and that the asset is moving in line with the market. 
  • 1 value denotes the precise alignment of an asset with the market trend. For instance, an ETF following the S&P 500 will have 1 as its Beta value.
  • >1 value denotes higher volatility, but the stock is still moving in line with the market.
  • <1 value or negative value indicates an asset is moving against the trend.
  • If all your stocks have more than 1 Beta value, they will have high volatility and hence are riskier.

How to assess an individual stock’s Beta value?

Calculating the Beta value of a stock is easy, provided you have the relevant data, such as the following:

  • The closing price of the share for the specific period you need, like a year, month, etc. and for the specific index, you are using for the comparison. 
  • The price changes value and its percentage for the period you want.
  • The stock and index prices change in percentage per day. 

To derive this value, use the following formula:

Finally, compare the movement of the stock and the index in relation to the movement of the index alone to derive the Beta value.

Difference Between Alpha and Beta

Both values, as you can see, help in predicting the value of your investment. While both are historical values and predictive of the future value, they have certain differences.

Benchmark used

When the benchmarks are not appropriate, the value of Alpha can be higher than its actual value. For instance, if you are investing your funds in tech stocks and using the S&P index, which is more focused on large capital markets, then your Alpha measurement may be high. But, against NASDAQ, which is focused on technology, the measure will indicate a lesser value.

Alpha or Beta measurement for performance assessment

If you want to make a profit from a bullish market, using the Beta value of the different equity funds can help you pick the right medium for entering the market. Finding stocks that have high Beta value will be apt.  

However, if you suspect there is mispricing, you should consider actively managed funds for ensuring better returns. Fund managers look for stocks that have high alpha value, so they get more from the investment.

Alpha helps in better stock selection

With the Alpha value, you can identify the efficacy of fund managers. This can be done by assessing the alpha value generated and the fund’s outperformance in relation to the standard index. You can also evaluate the performance by measuring incremental returns of a fund for a specific Beta value.

Alpha and Beta value significance

While an alpha value is proportional to the returns you can achieve from an investment, the beta value is of importance only in stocks with good growth potential. Beta is avoided by investors who do not like high-risk stocks and are happy with stable and consistent returns.

Summary

To summarize, both alpha and beta values are important based on your investment choices. If you are an active investor, the Alpha values help in assessing your performance. On the other hand, the beta values are more significant for assessing risk levels and organizing your portfolio. 

But, both values can be used for assessing the fund manager’s performance. In general, a high Alpha and low Beta is a safe bet. But, for those willing to take advantage of the volatility of high-risk stocks, a high Beta value is appropriate.

When the two are high, conservative investors will be forced to withdraw funds if the investment is not doing well because of the high volatility and risk of huge loss that the elevated Beta value indicates.


More investing

All →