Skip to content

Investing · · 5 min

Asset-Backed vs Mortgage-Backed Securities

Archived article from 24 May 2021. Prices, results and products change, so check the current details before you buy or trade.

Asset-backed securities, or ABS, refer to securities that are composed of consumer debts accumulated from various consumers and considered by the issuing institution as an asset. These debts are usually in the form of loans for buying homes, cars, etc. These loans are handed over to larger corporations (technically only on paper), who in turn sell them as bonds. Such bonds are backed by the assets against which the loans were issued, hence the name asset-backed security.

On the other hand, Mortgage-backed securities (MBS) are packaged bonds that are pooled together from several home loans.

How do Asset-Backed Securities (ABS) work?

Asset-backed securities are viewed as an asset by lenders. They are therefore tradeable, like any other security. However, for them to be sold, they are sold to trusts and other special-purpose vehicles, who package them into tranches of assets with specific maturity periods and sell them to the public.

The system is designed in a way that when consumers make payments, the money is channeled through to the owners of the assets. This way, the original issuer of the loans becomes a "conduit" for passing the payments. 

Issuers make a profit from the purchases made in the public market, while the owners of these assets profit as a result of the increase in yields accrued from the asset-backed securities.

How do Mortgage-Backed Securities (MBS) work?

MBS work like typical bonds, with the only significant difference being that they are paid monthly, unlike traditional bonds whose yields are paid annually or semi-annually. MBS is premised on giving buyers of bonds fixed income. The sources of this income are the payments traced to mortgage payments.

Types of MBS

Pass-Throughs: They are securities that package mortgage payments as products sold to investors. The pass-throughs act as channels through which borrower’s loans are transited to the investors. They typically become mature before the underlying mortgages mature.  

The payment sums are packaged in tranches equivalent to the mortgages’ principal amounts to actualize the shortened maturity period. However, since the rates of mortgage payments may fluctuate depending on the economy’s performance, the pass-throughs tend to have varied flexibility.

Collateralized Mortgage Obligations (CMOs): They are the modified forms of pass-throughs that package mortgage payments from different pools or tranches. This is significantly different from normal pass-throughs, which source both interests and principal payments to bondholders from a specific pool. CMOs are more diverse in terms of their sources of payment.

Types of ABS

Home Equity

These asset-backed securities operate in a manner that is largely similar to the workings of mortgages. However, unlike MBS, these types of securities are backed by payments from borrowers whose credit ratings are in the bad/poor category. With that in mind, it is important to weigh the balance between the potential returns and the comparatively higher risk exposure in these types of securities.

Auto Loan ABS

These are securities that are tethered to the payment of loans taken against the purchase of automobiles/cars. Therefore, their source of financial security includes payments related to servicing vehicle loans. These may include vehicle prepayments, monthly interests, and principal payments. 

Credit Card Receivable (CCR) ABS

These are securities whose payments are backed by payments from credit card usage. The financial backing of these assets will come from card interest charges, payment of principals, and annual card fees. Because of the varied nature of credit card usage, the payment pools for these securities grow as credit card usage increases and vice versa.

Benefits of ABS

  1. Have reliable security for the risk taken: Lenders' funds are safeguarded from potential default by borrowers. Since they push loans to other markets, they can generate money from "external" markets, thus enabling them to issue more loans to other borrowers. In the end, lenders minimize their risk.
  2. Have a solid asset-backed investment: ABS provide investors with alternative high-yielding investments, thereby giving them options outside government bonds and stocks.
  3. Low risk of default:  The assets to which securities are tethered are typically spread among several loans, most of which pay interests and principal payments. This is a reliable assurance that investors will get their money back.

Disadvantages of ABS

Like all investments, there are still risks involved with asset-backed securities, including the following below.

  1. Underlying uncertainties: the securities are from pools of numerous loan-linked assets, which investors may not be able to evaluate in detail to know the likelihood of default. This potentially exposes investors to losses, especially in instances of unforeseen economic slowdown.
  2. They have high prepayment risk: ABS face existential risks of low yields in case many of the borrowers end up paying their principal amounts earlier than projected. This can lead to reduced profits.
  3. Macroeconomic risks: ABS are potentially high-risk ventures in times of widespread economic underperformance, such as during recessions. This is because many people tend to default on payments during such times.

Advantages of MBS

  1. Have high returns: MBS is not only an alternative to government-issued bonds, but they offer yields that are typically higher than the other bonds.
  2. Have lower default risk levels: Lower risk is usually a result of the diverse nature of mortgages. Governments often back mortgages for their employees, which minimizes the risk of defaults.

Disadvantages of MBS

  1. Default risk: Securities without the backing of financially stable institutions such as government agencies generally have low creditworthiness and high default risk. Therefore, buying assets with less solid backing exposes you to potential losses.
  2. Changing Interest rates: Bond yields typically have an inverse relationship with bank interest rates. However, high rates of prepayment may lead to an under-par rise in MBS bond yields when interest rates fall and vice versa. This may lead to the underperformance of MBS relative to the other bond markets.
  3. Risk of longer extension: This typically happens when interest rises, thereby discouraging homeowners from paying their mortgages at the rates previously expected. In the end, the payments may be prolonged, and coupon yields may end up lower than previously expected by investors.
  4. Liquidity risks: MBS backed up by institutions with weak financial muscle are considered high-risk. Therefore, such securities may be difficult to sell as fast as government-backed securities.

Bottom line

ABS and MBS are both worthy investment options. However, before investing, you should assess their strengths and risk exposure.


More investing

All →