Investing · · 5 min
Auction Method and the NYSE Stock Prices
Archived article from 23 November 2020. Prices, results and products change, so check the current details before you buy or trade.
The NYSE is a colossus in the trading universe where it serves millions of retail and institutional investors. The primary function of the exchange is to ensure efficiency in the market at all times by matching bids and offers. Until 2010, the NYSE trading pits hosted noisy traders engaged in open outcry. The open outcry technique was how the traders facilitated the trading of orders from investors.
The stock market is not so perfect as to be left to its own devices. The NYSE uses the auction method to set the opening and closing price of shares it lists by taking and executing orders like MOO, LOO, MOC, and LOC. In the case of imbalances, DMMs and SLPs help the NYSE to adjust stock prices to achieve the NBBO price. SEC’s Regulation NMS requires brokers to guarantee NBBO prices to their customers.
The open outcry system was sufficiently efficient, but the introduction of electronic order matching systems produced higher efficiency levels. Perhaps you have been wondering why you do not see the noisy traders with their crazy and sometimes mysterious hand gestures on the trading floor. Well, automation happened.
Despite the change, the technique which the NYSE uses to determine stock prices remained. The technique resembles an auction, but one where buyers and sellers interact directly. Follow this guide to understand how the auction method happens.
What Is the Auction Method?
The auction market in the stock market terminology means buyers and sellers competing for the best stock deals. A buyer submits a bid that comprises the highest price he/she is willing and able to pay for a given company’s share. Simultaneously, a seller submits an offer that asks for the lowest price he/she is willing to accept for a given company’s share.
This process becomes an auction because it involves many buyers and sellers, and each one of them is competing for the best deal he/she can get. Why can’t we equate the NYSE’s auction market to regular auctions? In the first place, the market involves multiple buyers and sellers. Secondly, buyers and sellers engage directly, and the NYSE only executes matching orders.
Auction Method Before Market Opening
The NYSE conducts the opening auction before the official market open time of 9:30 am ET. How does it happen, and why is it necessary? Let us first clear why the opening auction is essential before going through how it happens.
A lot happens after the trading market closes the previous day. For example, companies release financial reports and other significant news, such as a management shakeup, etc. News plays a critical role in the direction that shares take, and investors would not want to miss an opportunity when it presents itself, even when it comes outside the trading hours.
In the event of groundbreaking news, the market is likely to experience heightened volatility when it opens. Therefore, the NYSE conducts the opening auction to ensure that the opening price reflects the sentiment in the market at that time. This way, the exchange can avoid surprises when the market opens.
During the opening auction, the NYSE receives two types of orders from as early as 7:30 am:
- The first one is Market-On-Open (MOO). This order is executable at the current price when the market opens officially.
- The other one is Limit-On-Open (LOO). LOO orders have a specific price at which investors wish the NYSE to execute, which means the trade will not take place if the market fails to reach the requested price.
By 9:28 am, the NYSE would have considered all the orders received, and then it begins the execution process. Trades only happen when there are matching bid and offer orders. The most prevalent price identified during the execution of orders goes on to become the opening price of a given share.
Auction Method Before Market Closing
The NYSE repeats the auction process before the market closes. The exchange begins taking Market-On-Close (MOC) and Limit-On-Close (LOC) orders early. These orders have characteristics similar to MOO and LOO orders. The MOC orders will execute at the final price of a share on market close. However, the LOC will not execute until the market closes at the predetermined price or better.
Nonetheless, not all LOC orders get matches. What happens then when liquidity is tight in the market? At this point, the NYSE facilitates the execution of a few of the LOC orders to offset imbalances. The market calls these orders the Closing Offset Orders (COO).
What Does the NYSE Do to Adjust Prices?
We mentioned previously that the NYSE calls in COO orders to offset imbalances in the market. How exactly does this happen?
Consider a pharmaceutical company – let us call it PharmX – that reveals negative test results on a major drug candidate late in the day. When the market opens the following day, the company’s share price is likely to experience a sharp drop. Given the circumstances, the NYSE has to make decisions to avoid risky volatility.
One likely decision the NYSE can make is to abandon the closing price of PharmX’s share during the previous trading session. In its place, NYSE officials assign a designated market maker (DMM) the responsibility of providing an adjusted price.
A DMM is a specialist market maker to whom the NYSE assigns a given number of listed stocks. The DMM’s primary function is to ensure the right liquidity environment for uninterrupted trading of the given stocks. Among other things, the DMM can delay the opening of trading of assigned stocks until volatility falls within a manageable range. Also, the DMM purchases limit orders (COOs) to maintain a functional market.
Apart from DMMs, supplemental liquidity providers (SLPs) help the NYSE to adjust stock prices. SLPs also act on specific markets (stocks) where they provide liquidity by creating a high volume on exchanges such as NYSE. Exchanges reward the SLPs via fees or rebates.
SLPs use powerful computers to engage in high-frequency trading. They aim to create the fairest price for both sellers and buyers in the market, which in technical terms is the National Best Bid and Offer (NBBO). The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) requires brokers – via Regulation NMS – to strive for the NBBO when serving their clients.
Conclusion
The NYSE does more than facilitate the trading of shares. Also, the exchange sets the price of stocks in a way that maintains an orderly market. The exchange adjusts stock prices with the help of DMMs and SLPs, all of which aim to maintain a National Best Bid and Offer price. Brokers are under obligation to guarantee the NBBO to their clients.