Skip to content

Investing · · 4 min

Commodity Short Squeeze Explained

Archived article from 9 April 2021. Prices, results and products change, so check the current details before you buy or trade.

Introduction

A squeeze as we know it represents pressure, either internal or external. In trading, short-sellers bet against the price of a stock or a commodity. Sellers will increase when the stock’s price continues to increase. However, the security reaches a point where the asset or security starts to gain price against the seller's position. In this case, sellers will be forced to buy rather than maintain their short position. 

An increased buying activity among traders tends to forestall further incurrence of losses among traders. The upward pressure on the stock among buyers forces the price to continue surging upwards. This pressure is what traders refer to as a squeeze. The premise of shorting a commodity is founded on the basis that traders will borrow or sell a stock and hope that its price will fall by the time they intend to buy it back.

Commodities and stocks

Commodities such as gold, copper, zinc, lead, or silver have had many short squeezes as traders move towards purchasing physical products. Unlike commodities, stocks are borrowed by traders without hedges (i.e., without any physical products), and they sell it hoping to make a profit if it loses value. Assets like silver or gold are not naked as stocks, and they are hedged by physical bullions stored in vaults. We are using silver because it is the by-product of metals such as copper, lead, and zinc that are mined by diverse companies. 

Short sellers such as bullion bankers may decide to go long on physical silver, i.e., buy silver from mining companies, but then go short in the paper market. This short position is more or less a balance where traders would hope that the value of the silver in the paper market goes up. A rise in the price of silver on paper will automatically push commercial silver higher on the physical space. A point to note is that traders who advocate for a silver short squeeze in most cases own physical silver.

Silver short

The beginning of September 2020 saw traders begin their selling their activity. The price of silver (XAG/USD) was 28.26930 before dropping slightly to 27.30049 as short-sellers puffed up their margin accounts. Prices move in a trading range as the trend seeks consolidation. The range occurs from September 1 until September 21, 2020. 

Figure 1: XAG/USD 

After confirming prices at the consolidation period, sellers have borrowed enough paper silver, and they increase their shorting activity. Prices decline from 27.30049 to 21.66523. The sharp decline is caused by the traders’ view that silver is overvalued against the US dollar. 

More traders continue to borrow more silver by opening more margin accounts. When prices reach 21.66523, many traders decide to hold on to their silver as collateral instead of increasing their selling activity. However, the sellers have made money by cashing in on the difference between the selling point and the final price of the commodity. 

After prices reach the tipping point, most sellers will now decide to start buying the silver. Here is where the short squeeze happens. 

Figure 2: Silver short squeeze

The silver squeeze happens amid two short retracement periods. Arguably, the same traders that had opted to go short are the same ones that are now opting to go long. Silver’s price increase happens as prices begin rising from 22.50000. Traders owning physical silver will profit from this squeeze since most have long positions on the commodity. Prices will increase due to the growing demand for silver among bullion traders and miners.  

Growing uses of silver

Silver is used as a thermal and electrical conductor. The growing use of solar power provides a boost to the utilization of silver as a concentrate for solar power. The low supply is an important feature for investors that will continue hoping the commodity increases in value over the years. 

Silver has high industrial demand, especially in the production of batteries, glass coatings, water purification, and photography, among others. Currency usage of silver, as well as jewelry, does not account for a higher application of the commodity as opposed to the industrial use. Investors were looking up to China’s increasing industrial-based stimulus into 2021 that spearheaded economic recovery. This stimulus also increased the demand for silver on a global scale, pushing the prices and value of the commodity. 

Figure 2 shows that the silver price rises from 21.87 on December 1, 2020, to 28.0000 on January 6, 2021. The retracements that occur during the squeeze period are not enough to pull prices lower.  The retracements also act as corrective points that allow traders to pay back brokers after the silver reached the buy point. 

The slight drop in the prices is a result of the low selling activity among traders before prices continue to rise. Continued purchases of silver (XAU/USD) will cause the price to rise further. At this point, investors that favor the short position continue to lose more of their investment. 

When is the short squeeze good or bad?

The short squeeze, as we can see in figure 2, is works for an investor if he is long or if he opts to buy the stock. The squeeze pushes the price on the upside. The squeeze works negatively to the trader that holds a short position. 

A squeeze will be visible when there is a rise in the price trend after a downtrend. The volume also increases as the squeeze gains momentum. Finally, traders should be up to date with the fundamental news that affects the demand for physical metals. 

Conclusion

A commodity short squeeze is an upward pressure that investors put on commodity prices after cascading efforts have earlier on pulled the value down. This article has used the example of the silver short squeeze. The silver price is affected by strong industrial and commercial demand that pushed prices up into 2021. Investors benefit from the short squeeze when they decide to go long on a stock rather than maintain their short positions. 


More investing

All →