Skip to content

Investing · · 4 min

Comparing Mutual Funds: Vanguard 500 Index Fund vs. Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund

Archived article from 3 December 2020. Prices, results and products change, so check the current details before you buy or trade.

Mutual funds provide the opportunity to invest in a multitude of carefully chosen stocks, including all major industries and large to small companies. The holdings of a single mutual fund can range from a few securities to thousands, which can help reduce the risk of loss due to problems in a particular company or sector.  VTSAX and VFIAX are two of the top-performing index funds that investors look to add to their watch list. In spite of being similar in a lot of aspects, there are quite a number of dissimilarities between them that investors have to keep in mind.

Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund (VTSAX)

Created on April 27th, 1992, VTSAX tracks a benchmark index’s performance,  measuring the investment return of the overall stock market. It possesses the following characteristics: 

  • The Investment approach for this fund is made in such a way as to efficiently track how the CRSP US Total Market Index performs,  which represents about 100% of the investable U.S. stock market. It includes micro-cap, small, mid, and large stocks, which are regularly traded on NASDAQ and NYSE. 
  • The fund invests by sampling the index. This means that it holds a diversified collection of securities, which approximates the full Index in terms of key characteristics.  These include industry weightings, market capitalization, and financial measures such as dividend yield and price/earnings ratio.
  • The fund’s largest holdings include companies from the technology and healthcare sectors in addition to others. Some of the largest holdings in this fund include the likes of Apple Inc., Microsoft Corp, Amazon.com Inc, Alphabet Inc, Facebook Inc, Berkshire Hathaway, Johnson& Johnson, Tesla, and Visa, just to name a few. 

Vanguard 500 index fund (VFIAX)

VFIAX possesses the following features:

  • The main aim of VFIAX is to track the performance of a benchmark index that measures the return of large-capitalization stocks.
  • It makes use of a passive management investment approach, designed to track the performance of the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index, which is dominated by the stocks of large US companies. 
  • When it comes to equity sector diversification,  the main sectors include Information Technology – 27.50%, Healthcare – 14.10%, Consumer Discretionary – 11.60%, and Communication Services – 11.10%.
  • It has shown a relatively moderate range of price fluctuations compared to other investments. It may experience larger or smaller price declines or price increases depending on market conditions. 
  • Some of the risks may be offset by owning other investments with different portfolio make-ups or investment strategies. 

If one has more than $10,000 to invest, then this fund is ideal for them. It ensures that the investor has the lowest expense ratio (0.5%). 

How do VTSAX and VFIAX differ?

When it comes to the stats, they differ in the number of stocks they hold, as well as their dividend yield. The difference between the dividend yields of the two funds, however, is very minimal. 

Points of Difference VTSAX VFIAX
Companies included VTSAX includes every publicly traded company on the New York Stock Exchange. VTSAX consists of an additional 3,100 shares compared to VFIAX. These are all shares of companies that are mostly minuscule compared to the S&P 500. VFIAX just includes the 500 companies of the S&P 500 Index. It’s a subset of the Russell 3,000 index and includes approx. One thousand of the largest securities based on a combination of their current index membership and market cap. 
Volatility It has experienced higher volatility and returns.  It has experienced lower volatility and returns.
Dividend yield  1.93% 1.83%
Investor Preference  Moderate to highly risk-tolerant investors who search for low-cost exposure to the U.S. stock market will find VTSAX ideal. It can also function as a single domestic equity fund in a portfolio. Investors with long term investment horizons and those who prefer the lower risk of large-cap equities will find VFIAX more suited as a core equity holding. The fund works best in a diversified portfolio as it does not focus on more conservative large-cap stocks.

Comparing the performance of the two funds

Let us take a look at the performance of each fund, according to Vanguard’s official fund report released on December 31, 2019.

  • VFIAX performance:
    • The index fund returned 31.46% for Admiral Shares and 31.33% for Investor Shares, closely tracking the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index, its target index. 
    • All 11 fund sectors posted double-digit returns, with the financial and information technology sectors performing the best.
    • The broad U.S. stock market achieved a return of about 31%. 
    • For ten years ending on December 31st, 2019, this fund posted an average annual return of more than 13%. 
  • VTSAX performance:
    • The broad U.S. stock market returned approximately 31% for the entirety of last year, with growth stocks outperforming value stocks. 
    • All 10 of the fund’s sectors recorded positive returns, with the industrials, financials, and technology sector contributing the most. 
    • The fund closely tracked its target index, the CRSP US Total Market Index. 

Final thoughts

Almost all investments have some sort of risk attached to them, and these funds are no exception. For instance, investors of Vanguard’s flagship S&P 500 Index Fund saw its value decrease more than four percent year over year after the economic turmoil of 2018. Apart from the fact that the U.S. stock market, equities can decrease in value-based on several factors. 

For any beginner investor who just wants to put some money in and leave it over the long term, both funds are good options. Both these funds have proven over the decades that they are reliable and can generate a return that will be passive. Both of these funds are most likely to provide almost the same returns in the coming years and have small expense ratios. For the average investor, both of these funds offer diversification. 


More investing

All →