Investing · · 5 min
What Does It Mean When They Say Gold Is a Hedge Against Inflation?
Archived article from 11 March 2021. Prices, results and products change, so check the current details before you buy or trade.
In the words of the legendary American banker and financier, J.P. Morgan, "Gold is money; everything else is credit." Morgan uttered these words in 1912, yet more than 100 years later, an overwhelming number of people still agree with him.
Goldbugs all over often speak of the precious metal as the true hedge against inflation, though what does this statement mean in real terms?
The topic of gold's value in the modern financial society can sometimes be confusing. What is the real purpose of investors buying physical gold? Is it an investment? Do they fear some doomsday event where the world will have to barter with gold? This article will attempt to answer all of these questions.
What makes gold valuable in the first place?
In the last few decades, gold has received a reputation of somewhat being 'anti-money.' Since the beginning of recorded history, there has been a fascination with the precious metal for its visual allure and status symbol.
The gold standard proved the commodity was necessary as part of a medium of exchange. When this system finally ended in 1971, gold still holds power as the most valuable noble metal globally. What are some of the reasons that gold still garners so much respect?
- Gold is a very scarce precious metal and extremely difficult to mine. We understand its crucial utility in products like jewelry and electrical appliances.
- People have long associated gold with the real measure of any economic wealth like it was centuries ago. They have essentially lost confidence in the current monetary system.
- Another interesting point is that central banks have added several thousands of tonnes of precious metal every year since 2010. The same reason why such institutions hoard gold is the same why countless are enthusiastic proponents of it.
- Unlike most assets, gold is one of the few that has no correlation and no liability or counterparty risk to any financial instrument. Even when fiat currencies weaken, gold maintains or increases much of its value (despite a dip from late 2012 to early 2016).
Physical gold is more of an insurance policy than an investment
Die-hard goldbugs or gold enthusiasts have long believed gold to be the only real preserver of wealth in any period (especially during some form of financial crisis). They believe this because most world economies operate on a debt-based system.
The so-called 'printing money out of thin air' expands the monetary supply, which is usually one of the causes of inflation. The purchasing power of fiat currencies gradually decreases yearly. Of all the money forms that ever existed, many enthusiasts view gold as the only one that retains (and, in some cases, increases) its value regardless of the economic situation.
On the one hand, physical gold is technically an investment (because its ounce price has and can potentially continue to increase). However, it does not produce the returns of typical investments like stocks. In its truest form, gold was never meant to be an investment.
Enthusiasts of the precious metal view it more as a 'hedge against inflation,' an 'insurance' against any financial crisis, an instrument that secures one's purchasing power.
Although this argument is meritable, how true is it? Can we observe a real-world example where gold did serve a purpose in a crisis like hyperinflation or another severe financial downturn?
Example of where gold maintained or increased in value during high inflation
For us to observe how true the statement of gold being a protector against inflation is, we need to see a real-life example of such occurring and whether this perception has been overstated or not.
Inflation is a regular economic phenomenon everywhere. In some extremely rare cases, however, it can become hyperinflation, which is the most catastrophic form of a financial crisis.
Most people lobbying for the purchase of physical gold (bars and coins) do so for fear of run-away inflation, where the use of precious metal may be a necessary means of exchange.
Typically in a high inflation scenario, there will be some government body intervening to introduce a new currency. Anyone holding gold during this crisis stands to gain substantially since they can convert the precious metal into a new currency.
This advantage still remains even if the affected nation continues with its currency.
Let's look at the performance of gold during one of the most hyperinflation events in Venezuela.
If one bought gold at $1,200 (its average price in 2018), their purchasing in dollar terms would have been roughly $988,600 in August 2018 (or 211 million bolivars). We can see an astronomical increase in purchasing power. This proves that gold does beat inflation by far.
Will high inflation occur in so-called first-world countries?
Analysts have noted hyperinflation occurred 55 times in the 20th century. Since Germany's hyperinflation in the early 1920s, such an event has occurred, on average, every three years.
The question becomes whether hyperinflation is possible in a country as notable as the United States, being that the US dollar is the world's reserve currency. Many assume that the so-called printing of money or quantitative easing accelerates the likelihood of high inflation.
So far, many first-world countries like America have survived through these practices, meaning that these reasons may not be strong enough. It seems unlikely any first-world country will experience hyperinflation anytime soon, though no one can predict the future.
The chances of such a catastrophic event occurring solely depend on how strong the faith is that people have about their native currency.
Conclusion
Aside from the utility of gold, we know in jewelry and electrical appliances, fundamentally, one of the motivations for price increases in the precious metal is usually investors' fear about any possible economic downturn like a recession or hyperinflation.
The argument over physical gold being a hedge against inflation is layered and will always continue. Ultimately, analysts typically advise investors to only allocate a small portion of their net worth towards physical gold.
While we have witnessed a circumstance where gold was tremendously more valuable during a rare currency crisis, there is no evidence this will always be the case due to factors we cannot determine presently.
What makes one decide if the precious metal is effective in high inflation is their unease over such an event occurring and their trust in the modern financial system.