Skip to content

Investing · · 4 min

What Is Naked Shorting in the Financial Markets?

What Is Naked Shorting in the Financial Markets?

Archived article from 8 December 2021. Prices, results and products change, so check the current details before you buy or trade.

Shorting an asset without first borrowing it or even asking if it may be borrowed is known as "naked shorting.” We can contrast this to conventional short selling, which begins with a borrower taking ownership of the stock.

Since shares are not borrowed before being shorted, the strategy is referred to as "naked" shorting. A contract may not be fulfilled due to the lack of accessible assets, and thus makes naked shorting a more risky option than short selling.

Because it is built on trading on assets whose existence is not assured, this form of shorting is marred with controversy. As a result of this, it is illegal in some jurisdictions, including in the United States.

How it works

Naked shorting is distinct from traditional short selling in that shares are sold without previously borrowing them. Thus, the seller, in this case, is selling shares they don't own, and the shares haven't been verified to exist. Consequently, it’s impossible to restore loaned shares to their original owner if the seller closes their position. Shares may not be delivered as a result of this.

Why use naked shorting, and what are its impacts?

Liquidity generation for lightly traded stocks with a small number of units available is the primary goal of this type of shorting. For the purpose of generating interest in the stock, brokers and dealers regularly swap these contracts, a practice known as "bona fide market-making."

Liquidity constraints might make it difficult to take a covered short position on an asset. In order to avoid the high borrowing costs, traders take a naked position and immediately buy the asset upon delivery.

The economic repercussions of naked short selling are a hotly debated topic, as is the case with any contentious trading strategy. An advocate of naked short selling may claim that the positive emotion of long holdings may be countered by allowing for negative sentiment.

The SEC, which prohibits naked short selling, has stated that the practice can artificially lower a stock's price and harm its ability to be purchased. Thus, a stock's liquidity is artificially increased by an unrestricted capacity to sell short shares without having to deliver them.

Benefits and limitations

Benefits

  • It helps to increase the liquidity of a rather illiquid asset.
  • As a result of this method, the amount of time and effort required to borrow or find out whether the security may be borrowed is reduced. It is basically delaying this endeavor until the contract is really fulfilled.
  • When the cost of borrowing security is prohibitive, traders are able to avoid these charges and, as a result of a lack of demand for borrowing, the borrowing costs fall to a more reasonable level.

Limitations

  • It can result in failure to deliver because the asset may not exist. This means that the seller is incapable of delivering the assets. As a result of the stock market meltdown of 2007/2008, there was a progressive restriction on naked shorting, ultimately resulting in its prohibition by the SEC. 
  • The major drawback of manipulating the market is that it might cause a security's price to fall to an unjustifiable level due to excessive selling pressure. The SEC considers this to be a violation of its rules. The problem is that it's difficult to tell which sales are legitimate and which aren't.

Naked shorting's the contentious side

There has always been a stigma attached to short-sellers. Even in the face of soaring share prices, expanding riches, and national success, they stir up much controversy.  But most market participants acknowledge that they serve a crucial service in identifying firms and industries that are overpriced by investors in the grip of excessive excitement.

They may also serve as a deterrent to those who seek to manipulate the stock market by spreading misleading information or otherwise artificially inflating the price of a stock. Short selling can help prevent the over-allocation of resources to enterprises and industries by bringing their values back down to earth.

Naked short selling was effectively outlawed on October 1, 2008, as a result of the SEC's "interim final" regulation that extended the short sale prohibition issued on September 18. SEC Regulation 10b-21, a naked short selling anti-fraud rule, covers short-sellers or any other market participants regarding their capacity or intention to deliver securities on time for settlement. Those who fail to meet their obligations are clearly breaking the law under this guideline. The SEC made the temporary regulation permanent on July 27, 2009.

In summary

In the financial industry, naked shorting is a method that involves selling an asset that the seller does not own, and they do not lend it. They then purchase the asset at a later date in order to complete the delivery of the item to the buyer. Essentially, it's a form of short selling.

Despite the fact that short selling is permitted, naked short selling is not. As a result of the SEC's rule on naked shorting, shorting shares that don't exist has become increasingly difficult for short-sellers.


Don't miss: The Best Forex Robots in 2021

More investing

All →