Skip to content

Investing · · 3 min

Why Chocolate Will Not Be So Sweet in 2021

Archived article from 14 January 2021. Prices, results and products change, so check the current details before you buy or trade.

  • Cocoa futures have declined since 2016 by 27% owing to price wars between the leading cocoa producers and the consumers in the chocolate market.
  • BREXIT deal negotiations may also affect cocoa beans prices as the UK is a net importer and re-exporter of the commodity in Europe.
  • World production of cocoa declined in the 2019/2020 season compared to the 2018/2019 season.

London Cocoa futures have declined by 27.80% in the past five years. It fell from a high of £2,385 per ton in June 2016 to £1,722 on January 5, 2021. Cocoa is a leading ingredient used in the making of chocolates and other sweeteners. It is applied in beverages as a flavoring agent as well as in confectioneries. However, this essential commodity has suffered from demand destruction and supply constraints due to production concerns. Further, BREXIT negotiations have delayed pricing implementations set to benefit cocoa farmers during the fiscal year 2020/2021.

Total return

From an investment perspective, it is crucial to consider the total return of the commodity’s ETF.

iPath Bloomberg Cocoa Subindex Total Return ETN (NIB) ETF has lost 41.6% in the past year. The last 52 weeks have seen the NIB ETF decline from an upside of 34.96 to a low of 24.69. The commodity seemed to take in the coronavirus scare at the start of the year with a 34.2% gain YoY in February 2020. However, this improvement has been replaced with a sharp decline in cocoa prices.

Cocoa prices peaked at $3,122 in mid-2016 per metric ton before declining to $2,134 per metric ton in October 2018.

A joint task force from the two primary cocoa producers globally: Ivory Coast and Ghana, worked to bring the selling price to a premium of $400 per ton (also known as the Living Income Differential - LID).

Some chocolate producers such as Hershey decided to buy their cocoa supply from the US futures market to avoid the LID this year, leading to a drastic drop in global prices (from January to March 2020). Towards the end of 2020, Hershey announced that it complied with the LID as it boosted cocoa farmers. This statement has done little to increase the demand for the product.

In the past five years, the global output of cocoa has soared 18% to a total of 4.7 million tons. Ivory Coast was the top producer at 4.7 million tons (an increase of 30% YoY), followed by Ghana at 800,000 tons (up 3% YoY). However, cocoa producers needed to reduce production below the market levels to force an increase in prices.

The cartel formed by Ghana and Ivory Coast, to force the LID price to $400 per ton, would leave the two countries with unsold cocoa produce in a year when heightened harvests are expected.

BREXIT fears

With the UK being one of the highest chocolate consumers in Europe, it is expected that the trade negotiations in BREXIT will affect the import and export of the commodity. Ivory Coast and Ghana are the leading suppliers of cocoa to the UK. The commodity is re-exported to other European countries such as Belgium, Germany, and the Netherlands. In 2017, it was ranked 7th in cocoa bean exportation in Europe. At the time, it exported 390 tons of cocoa worth €1.5 million.

Global trade fears in the 2019/2020 season led to a decrease in cocoa production worldwide compared to 2018/2019.    

Cocoa stocks increased in 2019/2020 by 1.6% from 36.0% recorded in 2018/2019. World production of cocoa decreased by 1.8% (a change of 87 metric tons YoY).  World grindings of cocoa beans also declined from 4,784 metric tons in 2018/2019 to 4,631 metric tons in 2019/2020.

Takeaway

Continued misunderstanding on price negotiations may affect cocoa prices into 2021. However, we still feel that cocoa prices may escalate based on the rising chocolate demand. Hershey’s announcement that it had reviewed the LID prices may also increase output in the long-run.


More investing

All →