Skip to content

Investing · · 4 min

Commodities vs Forex: Which Is the Best Market to Start?

Archived article from 29 July 2021. Prices, results and products change, so check the current details before you buy or trade.

Are you new to trading and don't know which market to choose? It is a frequent concern of people who invest their money or dedicate time to trading. 

If you talk to people from different age groups, you will find various answers. The youngest says crypto and forex are the most profitable markets. Others with more experience will tell you that stocks are the best option. However, more conservative investors believe commodities are the ideal market to start.

A single opinion should not define the answer for us. Therefore, it is essential to do our research.

This article will explain the main differences between one of the most popular markets, such as forex, and the commodities market, one of the oldest.

We will analyze which of the two is ideal for a beginner trader, taking into account the ease of learning, rules, brokers, versatility, among other things.

What are commodities?

They are the raw materials that most of us know, grow, consume, or use to manufacture other products. Let's look at the different types of commodities:

  • Soft: Corn, soybeans, wheat, coffee, cotton, sugar, cocoa.
  • Hard: Gold, silver, platinum, copper. 
  • Energy: Oil, natural gas, coal.

On TradingView, you can find all the assets by searching the futures tab.

The price of commodities will depend on the unit of measurement of each one. For example, gold is measured in one ounce, oil in one barrel, and copper in one pound. 

Finite commodities such as gold or silver tend to be more expensive than corn or sugar.  

Coffee, soybeans, and wheat are renewable products that can be cultivated again, but gold and platinum cannot.

If the asset is scarce, the price will increase, which plays an essential role in deciding whether to invest.

How are commodities traded?

You can trade them through futures contracts without buying the physical product. Futures can be with or without an expiration date, depending on what the broker offers.

On the Chicago Mercantile Exchange website, you will find the different brokers authorized to trade in the commodities market. Choose the one that best suits your needs.

What is forex?

It is the most liquid decentralized foreign exchange market, with volumes above $5 trillion.

If you have traveled to another country and exchanged the local currency, you have participated in a forex transaction.

How to trade in the forex market?

To trade in this market, you must do it through intermediaries known as brokers. Among the best known are FXCM and OANDA.

Most of the brokers allow you to open a demo account to trade with virtual money to familiarize yourself with the platform. Then, after you have tried the platform and tested your trading approach, you can open a live account if you wish.

Differences between forex and commodities

Both markets have their particularities. However, the main difference is that forex is not regulated, while commodities are regulated.

The forex market has been manipulated by large global banks such as Bank of America, HSBC, and JP Morgan. Undoubtedly, this is a negative aspect for traders who are just starting.

In 2019, five banks manipulated the foreign exchange market. Investigators determined that between 2007 and 2013, traders of these banks coordinated purchases and sales through chat rooms.

Although commodities are regulated, they are not exempt from problems. For example, they can be affected by events that are difficult to predict. Natural disasters, pandemics, and unusual weather conditions are some of the causes.

One of the most significant events occurred in 2020. US crude oil fell below $0 due to inventory build-up and low demand for the asset in quarantine times.

Volume in commodities is lower than in forex; this has advantages and disadvantages for a novice trader.

It may be easier to trade where there is sufficient liquidity, but the relatively low volatility may work against you, as you’ll have to use high leverage to make meaningful gains. 

On the other hand, commodities may have higher volatility, enabling you to catch bigger moves. However, lower trading volumes may increase the risk of sudden fluctuations that most novice traders aren’t prepared for.

Conclusion

As we have seen throughout this article, commodities seem to be a better option to get started in trading. However, this does not mean that forex is a bad market.

What matters is that you have a solid basic knowledge of each market you trade. So your job is to do a little more research on the strategies and aspects you should consider to start.

Some experienced traders have written books and told their anecdotes on the internet; this can be of great help if you are undecided.

Trading is all about probabilities. Good technical analysis combined with fundamental analysis and some relevant news will give you an edge when facing the big speculators.

Market volatility makes it attractive to short-term speculators, so if your objective is to enter and exit constantly, choose the market that you see as more volatile.

On the other hand, many investors put part of their capital buying gold or silver as a method of protection against a possible devaluation of the dollar or inflation.

If you are thinking of investing in commodities for the long term, you should apply fundamental analysis and research the economic projections for the next few years.


Don't miss: The Best Forex Robots in 2021

More investing

All →