Forex trading · · 5 min
Does It Really Matter if Your Forex Broker Is an ECN/STP or Market Maker?
Archived article from 11 May 2021. Prices, results and products change, so check the current details before you buy or trade.
Much of the existing trading literature has pushed a growing narrative on the distinctions between ECN/STP and market maker brokers. Most traders will probably see the former with more favoritism while the latter in a less favorable light.
Brokers are familiar with this discrepancy, and many supposed ECN/STP brands push their marketing towards being more transparent, using several terms like 'true ECN,' 'DMA' (direct market access), and 'no dealing desk.'
It does make sense most financial institutions would not outright call themselves 'market makers' because of the perceived conflict of interest, i.e., the notion of these brands taking the other side of their clients' trades.
With all of this in mind, it's worth having a conversation over the different execution models we know, begging the question of whether it truly matters if a broker is ECN/STP or market maker.
Brief differences between ECN/STP and market maker broke
The differences between the two execution models are:
- ECN/STP brokers (electronic communications network/straight-through processing) send their clients' orders' straight through' to liquidity providers with no intervention.
- Market maker brokers process their traders' positions directly to their internal liquidity providers or dealing desk.
It's a commonly-held belief ECN/STP firms make their money primarily from the spread and swaps; the profits and losses of their clients should go directly to the liquidity providers rather than to their balance sheet.
Contrastingly, aside from earning via the spread, swaps, and commissions (mostly on occasions if they are offering fixed spreads), market maker brokers also profit from their customers' losses. The latter attribute works both ways because any profits made by the client come directly from their pockets rather than an external liquidity provider.
There are some different things traders can experience with each:
- ECN/STP brokers tend to offer variable spreads because the pricing reflects the real forex market. Although such a feature is commendable, this may not be suitable for all strategies. Furthermore, nearly all these brands apply a commission on most of their trading accounts.
- Market maker brokers can typically provide fixed spreads that could be cheaper on a trade-by-trade basis, which is appropriate for some traders. The slight negative is the commission that's applied for this privilege.
The main reason why many traders dislike market maker brokers is due to the supposed conflict of interest. While this presumption is logical, we need to understand how the forex market is intrinsically structured.
The impact of forex being a decentralized market
Trading currencies occurs in a multitude of distributed forex providers through a dealer network with no central point of supervision.
Forex is also known as an OTC (over-the-counter) or off-exchange financial instrument because, unlike most stocks, there is no central exchange. In other words, the prices provided by each broker are not strictly uniform across the board.
For instance, the price of EUR/USD with one brokerage might be 1.200 and, on another, it could be 1.201, primarily because of the different spreads. Sadly, the disadvantage of an OTC market is this lack of transparency since there is no universally agreed-upon price, increasing the risks of manipulation.
Whether a broker sends orders to external or internal liquidity providers, it doesn’t make a difference in order execution.
Ultimately, the retail trader can't see exactly where their positions go, and this further adds to the lack of transparency. Most supposed no dealing desk brokers never publicly disclose where they send orders to.
Therefore, in reality, many brands are likely operating both execution models for business reasons, i.e., sending some orders to external providers and the rest to their dealing desk.
Regardless, this attribute is not something the average trader could verify from the internet or trading platform alone.
What most get wrong about market maker brokers
Most traders fear using market maker brokers because they supposedly take the 'other side of their trades,' which seems to create a conflict of interest. Unfortunately, many who portray this concept don't fully understand how market makers work.
Let's look at an example. With an ECN company, if one wanted to buy EUR/USD, the brokerage holds no liquidity since they pass the order to the liquidity providers. In a market maker broker, they will first look at liquidity from their clients.
So, the firm searches for other traders selling EUR or buying USD and matches them with this specific EUR/USD order. Should a deal not occur, the broker must provide the liquidity themselves by offering the euros and dollars.
So, the broker isn't technically trading against any individual client but is more of another participant dealing currencies amongst themselves and their customers. There is indeed a financial incentive in using this model. However, assuming they are regulated, they would not perform any malpractice.
Market maker brokers do offer advantages that ECN brokers can't
If we were trading directly through the real liquidity providers, it's unlikely we'd have accounts starting from 0.01 or 0.001 lots as banks and the alike trade much larger sizes. Some traders prefer fixed spreads to variable ones, which is only possible with a market maker broker.
These are only two examples of favorable trading conditions. Therefore, a market maker is not entirely bad provided they are not fly-by-night or 'bucket shops,' leading us to the next point.
Focusing on what's more important when choosing a broker
It's not to say clients should not consider the execution model a broker could be using, though there are far more vital things to observe. The first paramount factor is verifying the regulation of the financial institution.
Although it's not entirely perfect, it has rid of any possible manipulation from reputable brokers since it's bad for business from their perspective. Other crucial aspects include their customer service and how speedily they handle withdrawals.
Final word
The point of this article is not to irrefutably deny the existence of ECN/STP because, indeed, there are brokerages with no dealing desk. It's merely to emphasize that it's impossible to verify exactly where they send our orders from a retail trader perspective.
In forex, a counterparty always exists 'on the other side.' It's due to decentralization: for every buyer, there needs to be a seller and vice versa.
There are certain products one could experience from an ECN/STP provider they wouldn't benefit from a so-called market maker broker. However, there is nothing to fear with the latter regarding execution, assuming they've ticked all the other boxes regarding regulation.