Skip to content

Forex trading · · 4 min

ECN vs. Market Maker Brokers, Which Should You Choose As A Forex Trader?

Archived article from 30 June 2021. Prices, results and products change, so check the current details before you buy or trade.

Debates continue over whether so-called ECN brokers are better than market maker brokers or vice versa. While much of the literature suggests two distinct execution models, it's hard to verify as a retail trader as forex is still decentralized. Generally, the ECN structure is perceived more favorably due to the assumed transparency. 

Hence, as many brokers know this premise, they will base much of their marketing around it. However, in reality, brokers likely use both systems at any given time for various reasons. 

From a trader's perspective, it is possible to make a logical estimate over which mechanism a broker might be using for one's account and the pros and cons of doing so. But, ultimately, different traders are suited towards different models based on a few factors, which this article will explore further. 

Differences between ECN and market maker brokers

The primary difference between the two is that ECN supplies direct or 'straight through' access to the interbank market, while a market maker doesn't. At their core, currencies come from the interbank market, a group consisting primarily of large, recognized commercial banks like Citicorp, HSBC, JP Morgan, Deutsche Bank, etc.

Other substantial financial firms like hedge funds also form part of this category. Essentially, the interbank creates the entire forex market and acts as its largest liquidity provider. So naturally, a broker is the intermediary with the proper connections to this group that aren't possible with a sole retail trader. 

ECN, which stands for Electronic Communications Network, is merely a computerized system for connecting the interbank market with many forex dealers. A broker utilizing the ECN model passes their clients' orders through this system and makes their money mainly from the spread.

More importantly, no fiddling with the position is supposed to take place. An ECN dealer plays no role in setting prices. In contrast, a so-called market maker broker plays the role of being the liquidity provider without relying on the interbank, broadly 'making a market' for its clients.

The broker sets all prices and provides liquidity either from other clients' positions or from hedging or purchasing and selling the required currencies from other market makers. A market maker broker does also pocket from the spread or commission, though its profits also come from the losses of other traders, which creates a possible counterparty risk.

Pros and cons of ECN brokers

Now that we've covered the basics of how ECN brokers operate, it will be helpful to see their unique strengths and weaknesses for investors, along with an overall summary for which traders might benefit from this methodology.

Pros:

  • The spreads are competitive and reflective of the real interbank market exchange rates.
  • ECN brokers allow all forms of execution (expert advisors, hedging, scalping, etc.) as they do not have the responsibility of setting prices.
  • Expanding on the last point, an ECN dealer is perceived to not interfere with its traders' orders.
  • Traders experience faster execution as the broker is connected to substantially deep liquidity, allowing for consistent entries with little slippage and re-quotes. 

Cons:

  • As ECN brokers use variable spreads, these can increase erratically due to certain periods of high volatility and low liquidity.
  • Generally, these providers might have higher capital requirements. Moreover, cash-strapped investors cannot trade below a micro lot, which might mean increased monetary risks.

Overall, ECN dealers are better suited for users where low spreads aren't of much significance to execution, i.e., swing and position traders. On the other hand, scalpers and day traders or just high-frequency traders, in general, need more fixed trading costs, which they can only get from a market maker broker.

Pros and cons of market maker brokers

While market maker brokers aren't always seen in a favorable light, they are necessary for several reasons. Using this mechanism allows providers to offer special accounts like fixed spread and nano/cent and other unique conditions (higher leverage, guaranteed stop loss orders, etc.) not possible with ordinary direct market access.

As briefly mentioned, many providers will change between different execution models at any given time. Therefore, nowadays, there rarely is a broker exclusively using one system. Nonetheless, let's break the main pros and cons of market maker brokers.

Pros:

  • These dealers can provide fixed spread or fixed commission accounts which are particularly beneficial since trading costs remain consistent regardless of market conditions.
  • As these brokers essentially set prices that are mostly the same as the real-world currency market, they can also offer special accounts like cent, which have much lower minimum deposits.

Cons:

  • Perhaps the biggest detriment is the perceived conflict of interest since market maker brokers profit from their clients' losses. If the provider is unregulated or poorly regulated, they can manipulate prices, widen spreads, delay withdrawals, etc.
  • Some market maker brokers might not use an accessible platform like MetaTrader 4.
  • A few of these dealers also prohibit scalping, hedging, and trading with robots due to logistical concerns.

Despite the counterparty risk, market maker brokers are plentiful in forex and allow a safe and conducive trading environment when they are adequately regulated. Any trader looking for lower spreads, higher leverage, and other special conditions will benefit from using this kind of broker.

Final word

So, the ultimate question is which is the better option? Basically, no provider is technically better than another as both provide a highly efficient pricing mechanism and allow for super-fast execution with little chance for anomalies.

Although ECN brokers are seen as more transparent, they are usually not the best for high-frequency traders who need predictable costs. Market maker brokers are best for this group of investors and other traders looking for uncommon conditions not found with the former. 


More forex trading

All →